| Surname | North American Point of Origin | Residence (Rush, Shelby or Decatur) | Year Moved to R-S-D | First Prior Residence to R-S-D | Second Prior Residence to R-S-D | First Residence After R-S-D | Year Moved Away from R-S-D |
| Adams | / | S | 1881 | Johnson Co IN | Kentucky | / | / |
| Adams | / | R | 1843 | Shelby Co IN | Scott Co kY | / | / |
| Addison | / | R | 1827 | Preble Co OH | North Carolina | / | / |
| Akers | / | R | 1829 | Montgomery Co OH | / | / | / |
| Aldridge | / | R | 1820s | Ohio | Maryland | / | / |
| Allen | / | S | 1828 | North Bend OH | / | / | / |
| Amos | / | R | 1823 | Bourbon Co KY | / | / | / |
| Anderson | / | S | 1824 | Warren Co OH | Washington Co PA | / | / |
| Anderson | / | S | 1870s | Johnson Co IN | Clark Co IN | / | / |
| Andrews | / | S | 1840 | Kentucky | / | / | / |
| Applegate | / | R | 1846 | Fayette Co IN | Butler Co OH | / | / |
| Ardery | / | D | 1830 | Harrison Co KY | / | / | / |
| Armstrong | / | R | 1827 | Franklin Co IN | Ohio | / | / |
| Arnold | Virginia | D | / | Boone Co KY | Bourbon Co KY | / | / |
| Arnold | / | S | 1858 | North Carolina | / | / | / |
| Arnold | / | S | 1835 | Decatur Co IN | Campbell Co KY | / | / |
| Arnold | / | R | 1820 | Isle of Wright | / | / | / |
| Arnold | |||||||
| Ash | / | S | 1834 | / | / | Custer Co NE | 1834 |
| Badger | / | S | 1830s | Pennsylvania | / | / | / |
| Badgley | / | S | 1853 | Mason Co KY | Highland Co OH | / | / |
| Bagley | / | S | 1890 | Highland Co OH | / | / | / |
| Baker | / | S | 1831 | Pendleton Co Ky | / | Page Co IA | 1850 |
| Baker | / | D | 1847 | Butler CO OH | / | / | / |
| Ballard | VA | R | 1820 | Logan VA | Orange Co Va | / | / |
| Barnes | Maryland | S | 1827 | Pulaski Co KY | / | / | / |
| Barnes | / | R | 1837 | Bourbon Co KY | / | / | / |
| Basey | PA | D | 1840 | Harrison Co KY | / | Tipton Co IN | 1845 |
| Bassett | / | S | 1820 | Ohio | New York | / | / |
| Bassett | / | S | 1820 | New York | Vermont | Arkansas | 1873 |
| Bassett | / | S | 1824 | / | / | Taney Co MO | 1873 |
| Beale | / | R | 1823 | Cincinnati OH | New York | / | / |
| Beale | / | S | 1840s | Oxford OH | Vermont | / | / |
| Beard | / | S | 1880 | Muskingham Co OH | / | / | / |
| Beaver | / | R | 1820s | Harrison Co KY | / | / | / |
| Becker | New Orleans | S | 1840s | Moerheim Germany | / | / | / |
| Bennett | / | S | 1832 | Cumberkand Co NJ | / | / | / |
| Benson | / | S | 1840 | Butler Co OH | North Carolina | / | / |
| Bernhamer | / | S | 1848 | Indianapolis IN | Burken Nassau Germany | / | / |
| Berry | / | S | 1824 | Ohio | / | / | / |
| Beyer | New Orleans | S | 1870 | Dearborn Co IN | Alsace-Lorraine | / | / |
| Biddinger | / | D | 1870 | Hamilton Co OH | / | Oakland MI | 1905 |
| Bigger | / | R | 1836 | Warren Co OH | / | / | / |
| Billings | / | R | 1854 | Butler Co OH | Kent Co DE | / | / |
| Binford | / | R | 1826 | Northampton Co NC | / | / | / |
| Bishop | / | S | 1835 | Washington Co VA | / | / | / |
| Bishop | / | R | 1831 | Bourbon Co KY | / | / | / |
| Bitner | / | R | 1830 | Fayette Co IN | Tennessee | / | / |
| Blankenship | / | S | 1850 | New York | / | / | / |
| Bless | / | S | 1818 | Dearborn IN | Philadelphia PA | Illinois | 1853 |
| Boals | / | S | 1836 | Lycoming Co PA | / | / | / |
| Boblett | / | R | 1829 | Preble Co OH | Bedford Co PA | / | / |
| Boggs | / | S | 1830 | ||||
| Bollibaugh | / | S | 1822 | North Carolina | / | / | / |
| Bonner | / | D | 1836 | Wilcox Co AL | Abbyville SC | / | / |
| Bowles | / | R | 1825 | Harrison Co KY | Scotland | / | / |
| Boyd | Virginia | S | 1829 | Highland Co OH | Mason Co KY | / | / |
| Braden | NYC | D | 1821 | Scott Co KY | Westmoreland Co PA | / | / |
| Bradley | / | S | 1840 | North Carolina | / | / | / |
| Brison-Bryson | / | S | 1860s | Decatur Co IN | Marion Co IN | / | / |
| Brockman | / | S | 1820 | Kentucky | Virginia | / | / |
| Brooks | / | R | / | / | / | Jasper Co IL | 1850 |
| Brooks | / | R | 1849 | Nicholas Co KY | / | / | / |
| Brooks | / | S | 1849 | Boone Co KY | / | / | / |
| Brown | PA | S | 1830 | Fairfield Co OH | / | Pulaski Co IN | 1848 |
| Brown | / | R | 1824 | Kentucky | Virginia | / | / |
| Brown | / | S | 1867 | Hamilton Co OH | / | / | / |
| Brown | / | S | 1825 | Harrison Co OH | Laurens Co SC | / | / |
| Brown | / | R | 1824 | Kentucky | Virginia | / | / |
| Brown | / | S | 1830 | Rush Co IN | OH | / | / |
| Brown | / | S | 1868 | Harrison OH | / | / | / |
| Brown | / | D | 1825 | KY | / | / | / |
| Browning | / | S | 1839 | Switzerland Co IN | Mason Co KY | / | / |
| Buller-Bullard | NC | S | 1840 | Preble Co Ohio | Butler Co Ohio | / | / |
| Bunker | / | D | 1865 | Ripley Co IN | Illinois | / | / |
| Burnes/Burns | / | R | bef 1839 | NC | PA | Moultrie Co, IL | 1850-70 |
| Burns | / | D | c1840 | Jefferson Co IN | Harrison Co KY | / | / |
| Bussel | / | R | 1821 | Green Co OH | / | / | / |
| Cage | / | D | 1834 | Kentucky | / | / | / |
| Cage | / | S | 1833 | Fayette Co PA | / | / | / |
| Caldwell | / | R | 1837 | Bedford Co PA | / | / | / |
| Campbell | / | S | 1850s | Grant Co IN | Ohio | / | / |
| Campbell | / | S | 1821 | Franklin Co IN | Warren Co OH | / | / |
| Campbell | / | R | / | Fleming Co KY | / | / | / |
| Carney | / | R | 1852 | Ripley Co IN | / | / | / |
| Carter | / | S | 1830's | Rockingham Co NC | / | / | / |
| Cassady | / | R | 1819 | Preble Co OH | Montgomery Co VA | / | / |
| Castator | / | S | 1831 | Pendleton Co KY | / | / | / |
| Cater | / | R | 1845 | Fleming Co KY | / | / | / |
| Cauley | Boston MA | R | 1884 | / | / | / | / |
| Chambers | / | D | / | / | / | MO | / |
| Child | / | D | 1828 | Kentucky | Maryland | / | / |
| Clark | PA | R | 1834 | Guilford Co NC | Henry Co IN | Muncie IN | 1950 |
| Clark | / | S | 1841 | Warren Co OH | / | / | / |
| Clark | / | S | 1840 | OH | / | Adair Co KY | 1857 |
| Clarke | / | S | 1830's | Lebanon Ohio | North Hampton England | / | / |
| Clarke | / | S | 1824 | Manchester England | / | / | / |
| Clayton | VA | S | 1825 | OH | VA (now WV) | ||
| Clifton | / | R | 1830's | Franklin Co IN | Cincinnati OH | / | / |
| Coffey/Coffee | / | S | 1828 | Rockingham Co NC | / | / | / |
| Cole | / | S | 1820s | Connersville IN | Vermont | / | / |
| Cole | Saco, Maine 1633 | S | 1822 | Shaftsbury, Vermont | Plymouth, Massachusetts | / | / |
| Coleman | / | S | 1820 | North Carolina | / | / | / |
| Collingwood | Elmira NY | D | 1865 | Venango Co PA | / | Rush Co IN | 1875 |
| Collins | / | R | 1820's | Fleming Co KY | / | / | / |
| Collins | / | S | 1820 | Madison Co KY | Perquimans Co NC | DeKalb - Linn Co MO | 1870 |
| Conover | / | S | 1815 | New Jersey | / | / | / |
| Cooper | / | S | 1830 | Rush Co IN | Pennsylvania | / | / |
| Copeland | / | S | / | / | / | Page IA | 1850 |
| Cory | / | S | 1827 | Preble Co OH | / | / | / |
| Cotton | / | S | 1822 | Hamilton Co OH | / | / | / |
| Courtney | / | S | 1855 | Harrison Co KY | / | / | / |
| Cowger | Pennsylvania | R | 1855 | Highland Co OH | Bedford Co PA | Jasper Co IL | 1855 |
| Coy | / | D | 1816 | Harden Co KY | / | / | / |
| Crane | / | R | 1830's | Harrison Co KY | / | / | / |
| Creath | / | D | 1861 | Holten IN | / | / | / |
| Creed | Va | R | 1820's | Highland Co OH | Monroe Co VA | / | / |
| Crim | / | S | 1830 | Guilford Co NC | / | / | / |
| Crisler | / | S | 1834 | Boone Co KY | / | / | / |
| Critser | New Jersey | D | 1820s | Warren Co OH | Hampshire Co W VA | Jasper Co IN | 1881 |
| Crosby | / | S | 1849 | Ohio | / | / | / |
| Crosby | / | S | 1837 | Mason Co KY | / | / | / |
| Crum | / | S | 1842 | Fayette Co IN | Juniata Co PA | / | / |
| Culbertson | / | R | 1828 | Pennsylvania | / | / | / |
| Curson | / | S | 1850s | Lincolnshire England | / | / | / |
| Cutsinger | / | S | 1822 | Washington Co KY | / | / | / |
| Dake | / | S | 1820s | Shenandoah Valley VA | / | / | / |
| Danner | / | R | / | / | / | Delaware Co IN | 1833 |
| Dargin | / | S | 1835 | Clinton Co KY | / | / | / |
| Davidson | / | S | 1821 | Tennessee | / | / | / |
| Davidson | / | R | 1823 | New Jersey | / | / | / |
| Davis | / | S | 1880 | Jackson Co IN | Kentucky | / | / |
| Davis | Maryland | S | 1820 | Fayette Co IN | Fleming Co KY | / | / |
| Davis | Jamestown, VA | R | 1828 | Preble Co OH | Mercer Co KY | Madison Co IN | 1849 |
| Davis | / | D | 1837 | Franklin Co IN | / | / | / |
| Davis | Maryland | D | 1825 | Maryland | Kentucky | / | / |
| Day | / | S | 1838 | Dearborn Co IN | Ohio | / | / |
| Derry | / | D | / | / | / | / | / |
| Diese | / | S | 1826 | Germany | / | / | / |
| Dilts | / | S | 1869 | Decatur Co IN | Muskingham Co OH | / | / |
| Doble | / | S | 1828 | Boone Co KY | Botetourt Co VA | / | / |
| Dodderidge | / | D | 1822 | Franklin Co IN | Virginia | / | / |
| Dodds | / | S | 1848 | Montgomery Co OH | / | / | / |
| Dollman | / | S | 1851 | London England | / | / | / |
| Donahue | / | S | 1860s | Bellmullet Ireland | / | / | / |
| Dorsey | / | D | 1865 | Oxford OH | / | Shelby Co IN | 1860 |
| Duncan | / | R | 1834 | Decatur Co IN | Marion Co IN | / | / |
| Dunn | / | R | 1831 | Monroe Co VA | / | / | / |
| Earnest | / | R | 1833 | Sevier Co TN | / | Jasper Co IL | 1840 |
| Earnest | / | R | 1833 | Green Co TN | / | / | / |
| Eberhart | / | S | 1828 | Warren Co OH | Pennsylvania | / | / |
| Eck | PA | D | 1853 | Berkeley Co VA (now WV) | Frederick Co MD (now Carroll Co) | / | / |
| Edkins | / | D | 1835 | New Jersey | Gloscester England | / | / |
| Elder | / | D | 1826 | Lincoln Co KY | / | / | / |
| Elliott | / | S | 1842 | Warren Co OH | Pennsylvania | Missouri | 1867 |
| Elloitt | / | D | 1826 | Jennings Co IN | Kentucky | / | / |
| Elsberry | / | S | 1840 | North Carolina | / | / | / |
| Elstun | / | R | 1820 | New Jersey | France | / | / |
| Endsley | South Carolina | S | 1820s | Wayne Co IN | Scotland | / | / |
| English | / | R | 1835 | Preble Co OH | Abbeville District SC | / | / |
| Enos | / | S | 1852 | Ohio | / | / | / |
| Ensimger | / | S | 1827 | Rockbridge Co VA | / | / | / |
| Ensminger | / | S | 1830s | Vermont | / | / | / |
| Ertel | / | R | 1840 | Franklin Co IN | Germany | / | / |
| Evans | / | S | 1850s | / | Shropshire England | / | / |
| Evans | Maryland | D | 1837 | Hamilton Co OH | Maryland | / | / |
| Evans | / | D | 1837 | Hamilton Co OH | / | / | / |
| Ewing | / | D | 1828 | Kentucky | Maryland | / | / |
| Ewing | / | R | 1820 | Kentucky | / | / | / |
| Feaster | PA | S | 1837 | Rush Co IN | Bedford Co PA | / | / |
| Fenely | / | D | 1835 | ? | / | / | / |
| Ferree | / | R | 1836 | Ohio | North Carolina | / | / |
| Fessenbeck | / | S | 1847 | Cincinnati OH | Germany | / | / |
| Fields | Virginia | S | 1830 | Rockingham Co NC | / | / | / |
| Fish | New Jersey | D | 1850s | Franklin Co IN | Gloucester Co NJ | / | / |
| Fisher | / | S | 1823 | North Carolina | / | / | / |
| Fisher | / | R | 1821 | Clermont Co OH | / | Shelby Co IN | 1870 |
| Fix | / | S | 1821 | Ohio | / | / | / |
| Fleming | / | S | 1849 | Pennsylvania | / | / | / |
| Fleming | / | S | 1878 | Fountain Co, IN | Preble Co, OH | Marion Co, IN | 1970 |
| Florea | / | R | 1837 | Adams Co OH | / | / | / |
| Folger | / | R | 1827 | Union Co IN | Stokes Co NC | / | / |
| Foreman | / | S | 1810 | NC | ?Stokes Co NC | / | / |
| Foust | / | R | 1832 | Ohio | Virginia | / | / |
| Foxworthy | / | R | 1849 | Fleming Co KY | / | / | / |
| Fraker | / | S | 1854 | Johnson Co IN | Willington DE | / | / |
| Fraley | Maryland | D | 1855 | Rockingham Co VA | / | / | / |
| Frazee | / | R | 1829 | Bracken Co KY | / | / | / |
| Fugit | / | D | 1819 | Franklin Co IN | Russel Co KY | / | / |
| Gahimer | / | R | 1834 | Germany | / | / | / |
| Garrett | / | S | 1829 | Virginia | / | / | / |
| Gates | / | R | 1827 | Ross Co OH | Pennsylvania | / | / |
| Gatewood | / | S | 1819 | Lexington KY | / | / | / |
| Gatewood | / | S | 1822 | Floyd Co KY | / | / | / |
| German | / | R | 1827 | Guilford Co NC | / | Madison CO IN | 1875 |
| Gillespie | / | S | 1853 | Butler Co OH | Middletown MD | / | / |
| Gilson | / | R | 1820s | Virginia | / | / | / |
| Girton | / | S | 1851 | Butler Co OH | / | / | / |
| Gobel | / | S | 1854 | White Pidgon MI | / | / | / |
| Goodrich | / | S | 1820 | Wheelington WVA | / | / | / |
| Goodwin | / | S | 1822 | Butler Co OH | / | / | / |
| Gordon | / | S | 1830s | Ohio | / | / | / |
| Gordon | / | S | 1820 | Cumberland Co PA | / | / | / |
| Graham | / | S | 1868 | Kentucky | / | / | / |
| Gray | / | S | 1849 | Preble Co OH | / | / | / |
| Gray | / | S | 1854 | Illinois | Preble Co OH | / | / |
| Gray | / | R | 1833 | Bourbon Co KY | / | / | / |
| Green | / | S | 1856 | Rush Co IN | / | / | / |
| Green | / | R | 1830 | Kentucky | / | / | / |
| Green | / | S | 1889 | Bartholomew Co IN | Pennsylvania | / | / |
| Gregory | Virginia | S | / | Washington Co KY | Halifax Co Virginia | / | / |
| Gryden | / | D | 1850 | Stockholm Sweeden | / | Kansas | 1870S |
| Guile | / | S | 1830s | Cincinnati OH | / | / | / |
| Gwinnup | / | R | / | NJ | / | / | / |